Saturday, January 31, 2015

On The Ghost of Formalism




A Few Brief and Subjective Thoughts on Form, Formalism, and Those Considered "Formalists," Or,  Dispatches From This Godless Endeavor

“For a non-debate, this can get kinda heated.”


Why Do I Pilot An Eva?

Quite frankly, I want to be writing a book about Final Fantasy VII right now. I was, in January, but then all this happened and this happened. These things seem to happen continuously in the games criticism community, and the result is the same: I am left doubting the value of my own work.

My work, which has been curated by Critical Distance, a blog dedicated exclusively to collecting good games criticism, and published on The Ontological Geek and in magazines like Five Out Of Ten and Memory Insufficient, all of which exclusively exist to compile good essay writing. Not reviews, not news, not any of the stuff you could dismiss as “fluff” even when it’s well-written . My work has been valued by groups of people who exclusively value quality essays and this is the state I am left in when phraseology like “childish make-believe, imaginary dragons, badly written dialogue and unskippable cutscenes” shows up and makes me feel like none of my work, none of the ideas I’ve been building and expressing since I was a teenager, have left any impression whatsoever on the people who teach games studies.

Someone asked me recently whether these continuous feuds between “formalists,” my peers, and myself actually “get anyone anywhere.” My response was two-fold: firstly, no, usually everyone is spinning their wheels about their already expounded-upon approaches, and while codifying those things can be both fun and interesting, we’re not talking about games, we’re talking about theory. I like theory. I like games a fuck of a lot more. Secondly:

SHINJI
Asuka, why do you pilot an Eva?

ASUKA
To exhibit my talent to the world, of course.


SHINJI
You mean to prove that you exist?


ASUKA
Yeah, something like that.

Neon Genesis Evangelion,

Episode 12: “She Said: Don’t Make Me Suffer For Your Personal Hatred”

Hideaki Anno
I want to end this.

Zolani Stewart, who edited this article with others:


As another debate on formalism rears its head, games writers of various stripes and positions, mostly on the lower ends of recognition, income, and axes of privilege, ask themselves again: why does this keep happening? It’s clear at this point that the way established games studies academics interact with “amateur,” middle-state, noninstitutionalized critics produces nothing fruitful. This isn’t a symptom of the past two weeks but a years-long pattern, a “debate” long tainted with frustration, anxiety, microaggression, condescension, disrespect, misinterpretation and lack of any mutual understanding. Toxic interactions, and the old baggage of begrudged men thrown onto the laps of critics looking towards alternative approaches, mostly writers struggling for recognition and stability in a space that’s endlessly hostile towards their methodology and practice, mostly women and people who are not white.

So what is happening here? What can be done about this? Because it’s apparent that something is very wrong. And it’s apparent that there are dynamics at play here that aren’t designed to lean towards Austin, myself, or our peers, that there are terms in these “discussions” we have not decided but are somehow obligated to subscribe to.

Whatever the answer, I think I speak for many writers in the space I engage in that these shitty patterns have to stop. I want to end this, so I, like Austin, can move on to better conversations, and focus on better people, to be frank. But I guess before that can happen, there are words that still need to be said, and ideas that need to be made clear, regarding form, “formalism,” method, and the alternative critical space.


To My Peers: "Form" and “Formalism” Are Awful, Loaded Words.

When Brendan Keogh and Zolani Stewart talk about "form" they speak in completely different languages, and the problem is that "form" is so vague a word because it inherently includes almost everything. Based on a discussion Zolani Stewart and Lana Polansky and I had on Wednesday, I’d have a hard time telling you what isn’t a part of “form.” Systems and abstractions are equal measures of form. I realize that this doesn’t make the truism “games criticism is bad about form” any less true no matter what angle you’re coming from, but all that that truism means is that games criticism is bad at a lot of different topics. Whether games criticism actually is bad at these things, or whether critics can be incredibly self-flagellatory is up for debate, but given examples I’ll cite later, I certainly doubt the former is true.

Formalism began as a style of art and music criticism that stated that you could determine the meaning of a work purely through it’s “form.” Before then, criticism would often rely on historical or autobiographical evidence to suggest the meaning of these works. A similar idea in literature manifests as The Death of The Author, wherein you’re able to derive the meaning of the text from the text itself. Film formalist study is more or less the study of film direction from a technical standpoint. that is, it focuses on form, but does not find it “exclusive” in the way painting formalism might. Games “Formalism” as it is doesn’t easily fit into any of those.

Holism Is Important, But Specialization Is Important As Well.

Critics who focus on facets of form other than “systems” (that is to say, what is usually understood as gamer input and haptic feedback,) do not claim a true and whole understanding of how a game works, what a game is, or what a game means, but ludocentric writing often claims that one can disregard facets of games outside of “systems.” This is, admittedly, more a quality of the commercial games writing that I see as descending near-directly from the ludocentric writings of “formalists.” However, when the need for an understanding of form outside of systems, especially narrative, is brought up, there’s Frank Lantz or Raph Koster again, showing up in your mentions, insistently reasserting the importance of systems. Regardless of what is intended, it is feels like shouting down worthy ideas and writers.

“. . . [I]f what we’re saying is so inconsequential, why is it being treated like it needs to be nipped in the bud?”

Lana Polansky on Twitter

This is important to me because I feel the only people whose approaches are ever accused of not being holistic are writers who specialize in “storytelling.” Likewise, I’ve read critics whose work is sold as showing a “comprehensive” understanding of a game that fails to show understanding of even the basics of storytelling.

Game Reviews, Being Ludocentric and Tech-Fetishistic As They Often Are, Are Actually Ultra-Concerned With “Form!”

If “systems” are a subset of form (they are), then by god game reviewers are some of the most dedicated, though not necessarily talented, formalist critics out there. The ability to assess narrative beyond the surface-level entertainment players enact is utterly non-existent in the commercial game review. The ability to dig deep into systems? On rare occasion lacking, as in the case of IGN writer Chris Roper’s infamous review of God Hand, and sometimes utterly boundless, as in the case of Kirk Hamilton’s biblical tome of a Destiny review published last year on Kotaku. This isn’t even to mention the incessant adulation of graphics, sound design, and atmosphere, all of which are formal qualities!
Despite The Impression Some Seem To Have, “Young” Game Critics Are Actually Quite Good At Assessing Form Within Their Work.
The problem of course is that what we call “formalism” has very little to do with form in any broad sense. “Formalists” are not concerned with form, they are concerned with systems. In fact, as Frank Lantz wrote in “More Thoughts on Formalism,” it seems to be the impression of formalists that ideas like “sound design” fall under an even more nebulous idea: “Content.”

Here are writers who understand form in a broad sense.

Here’s Zolani Stewart talking about the relationship between abstract painting and level design in Sonic Adventure 2 back in December.

Here’s Lana Polansky talking about how the tone and poetics differ between the television show Twin Peaks and the fan adaptation game of the show (which I might add assesses this change in tone almost entirely through the game’s use of mechanics).

Here’s Stephen Beirne’s ongoing project talking about meaningful cinematography in Final Fantasy VII.

Here is Mark Fillipowich on the camera as a formal element that obscures and bends understanding of spaces and objects.

Here is Brendan Keogh on phenomenology and the close reading as an alternative to traditional games studies approaches, and Lana Polansky pushing for similar approaches two years earlier.

I wanted to make my examples as recent as possible, but for shits and giggles, here’s my May 2013 essay about Metal Gear Solid that analyzes the gamer’s relationships between both the camera as their window into the game world, and the gamer’s autonomous use of the radar to guide Solid Snake through Shadow Moses.

There is an impression that form often goes ignored or underappreciated in the videogame criticism produced by younger writers categorized as “anti-formalists.” We see this sentiment in Raph Koster’s Critical Proximity talk, and Frank Lantz’s recent blog post. This is, plainly, wrong. It makes zero sense to consider those opposed to “formalism” as “anti-formalists” when what is being represented in this writing is simply a broader understanding of form.

Not all discussions about form need to be about formalism, because form isn’t the sole domain of people who call themselves (or find themselves called by others) formalists.



I Am No Longer In College Partially Because Games Curriculum Is Ludocentrist and Tech-Fetishistic.

Scholars, who struggled to establish game studies as a discipline within academia, chose to focus on procedural styles of play as a strategy for establishing an independent and legitimate field of study, but it was still a hard sell. Programming and animation courses, in particular, train laborers that are useful for a variety of creative media industries—not just the games industry. By combining play studies with programming and animation, a games curricula emerged that focused on games that are designed around both ludocentric and tech-fetishistic rhetorics.

To be a game design major at my college, you had to prioritize courses in art and programming, and the only required writing class was English Composition. To me, the purpose of a secondary education in games writing would have been to establish formal mentorship opportunities between myself and seasoned industry professionals. Programmers, artists, and systems designers have this opportunity. Those who wish to tell stories through the medium of videogames don’t, and this absence evinces a toxic environment for games writers, one where their work is devalued.

The fact that writers are often hired as consultants at the end of development, when a game is already near beta, when the bud.get is running out, reflects this. The horrid state of storytelling in commercial console games reflects this. The fact that both Anthony Burch and Walt Williams have left the industry within months of each other reflects this. That writing for games is discussed like fucking softcore screenwriting reflects this:

Story in a game is like a story in a porn movie. It's expected to be there, but it's not that important.

John Carmack, quoted in Masters of Doom by David Kushner


There Is A Disconnect Between What Is Called “Formalism” In Games and Those Figures We Call Formalists, According To Them.

The impression that people seem to get from the work of games formalists is that “What a game is as an experience can be derived entirely from it’s rules and it’s systems,” a philosophy most notably laid down by Ian Bogost in his book, Unit Operations:

"(…) games create complex relations between the player, the work, and the world via unit operations that simultaneously embed material, functional, and discursive modes of representation."

The problem, as has been noted in every regurgitation of the long-dead ludology/narratology discussion, is that existing interpretations of Bogost’s work do not take into account how game developers choose to contextualize their mechanics through or alongside other forms: music, aesthetics, tone, or to move into even more abstract territory, “poetics” as Lana Polansky and Zolani Stewart put it. Their definition of “systems,” with regard to videogames, ignore rhetorical texts (of any kind) enacted by the gamer.

There are rules, conditions, mechanics—what is codified as “systems”—and that method/ology is seriously challenged by the the rest of the game existing alongside it. Narratives, scripts, music, tone, aesthetics, and poetics are each their own sort of “systems.” This confluence of systems creates an economy where each factor is contributing to a larger whole.

This is not a debate: games are everything inside of them.

[W]hen I frame it as “the coat of paint could be different” the underlying message changes to “the coat of paint doesn’t matter.” It can be easy to agree that the paint does not matter when so many games treat the coat of paint as if it does not matter, or as if it was just a coat of paint and not a painting, or if the coat of paint was not as or more important a thing than the game under it.


Based on things Frank Lantz sent at me after my initial twitter blowup about his article, this systems-focused view does not seem to jive entirely with, at the very least, what he wants to project as being his approach to games criticism, and based on Raph Koster’s talk that he gave at Critical Proximity, this also seems to not be the case for him either.

Quite frankly, I am a busy and, as of recently, a poor man, and I have to spend as much of my own time writing my own work as possible before I can take the time to navigate the distinctions between their idea and their intention. I guess what I’m saying is, I need substantive proof that this reductive approach isn’t actually the reality of how Eric Zimmerman, Raph Koster or Frank Lantz approach videogames before I’m remotely at risk of giving a shit. Lemme tell you why.


Games “Formalists” Do Not Have A Good Reputation.

As I came into this community a year and a half ago, formalism was a boogieman of prescriptivist statements about what is and isn't a game that revolved around what I've articulated as a "ludocentrist" rhetoric in extreme format, as embodied by Raph Koster’s infamous statement that Dys4ia, a game about trans womanhood and transitioning, was a “slideshow” and could be “made in powerpoint.” (I’d like to bookmark for the future that Dys4ia actually communicates it’s meaning mostly through it’s systems and minimally through narrative text, i.e, it actually fits a “formalist” design philosophy.) Regardless of one's interest in systems, it was and is a label to be avoided, and it became as such because the old guard of “formalist” games studies figures became known for some seriously asinine behavior on top of highly contested views on games.


You Can Draw A Direct Rhetorical Line From Ludocentric “Formalist” Approaches, To The Philosophy of  Commercial Games Reviews.

To expound, it is not a stretch to make a rhetorical connection between these statements, some of which are theoretical common statements often seen on forums, and literal statements by known and respected figures:

  • “A game’s rules and the affects and effects of it’s systems and mechanics are how we derive the meaning of the game in question.”
  • “Who cares if the story is bad? Does it play well?”
  • “Who cares if the story is horrendously offensive to minoritized gamers? Does it play well?”
  • “Fuck politics, I just want to talk about games.”
  • “This game is so pretentious, I’m really not even sure if it is a game.”
  • “What if it was me that was trying so hard to get something out of this walking simulator, that I had lost sight of the fact that it literally is a game about prancing around a lo-fi island for half an hour?” - Mike Rose, Gamasutra, February 2013
  • “I like Anna Anthropy’s work, but I also try to be clear-eyed about the fact that a lot of Dys4ia could be built in PowerPoint and isn’t a game.” - Raph Koster on his blog, July 2012. (I want to make it exceptionally clear, for the record, that I am well aware that Anna Anthropy herself is not an unassailable example of greatness as a human being, I am merely discussing the ramifications of her work in games spaces.)

This is especially damning when Koster himself could be seen discussing with people from The Hashtag in public, on twitter, as though they ever had legitimate ethical concerns. He suggested diplomacy rather than the deserved and sustained condemnation The Hashtag has gotten from anyone who actually fucking gets it. This is despite the fact that it had been established within one week that all of the initial clamour about “ethics” was a haze for harassing women alternative games developers.

And while other figures who I have name checked here and more who will be name checked later did not nearly participate in The Hashtag to this level (and some were explicitly opposed to it) there has genuinely been a lack of acknowledgement of the ideological history that this harassment campaign is connected to.

When, as a critic or analyst, you invest your time and capital in the definition of proper form, your analytical projects are always, necessarily, about the inclusion and exclusion of both people and ideas within a perceived community. Naming ludocentrist rhetorical analysis as a thing is similar to the ways in which some will harp about what is/n’t a game is a political move that intends to disassociate particular critics or methods of critique from a perceived community.

However, these two discourses have radically different histories. In context, the naming of game (and play) is a persistent, ritual debate that has long-defined the professional careers of many white, older men. “Ludocentrism” is in part coined to respond to this, though in my initial definition I highlighted technical theory rather than sociological elements. Recognizing ludocentrist rhetoric is, thus, also about recognizing dismissive critiques that, ultimately, justify, validate, or valorize the otherization of “outsiders” or “non-gamers.”


The Formalists Have Good Jobs.

The simple matter is that the school of folks regarded as "formalists"  are being paid to teach games at schools with well-funded programs and write about them while others struggle. This is especially tragic given that it has led me and others to overgeneralize regarding “games academia” leaving good folks like Todd Harper flapping in the wind. Let’s be clear, institution is a big part of the problem here, but the shitty behavior and shitty ideas are emanating from a fairly specific group of people.

What amount of establishment my peers or I have been able to achieve has been entirely without the assistance of existing structures of game studies.


The “Formalists” Have Recognition.

Frank Lantz and Eric Zimmerman—who wrote the much-discussed article on the supposed “Ludic Century”—are both professors at New York University. Ian Bogost has a doctorate, is a distinguished scholar, tenured professor at Georgia Tech, and former-guest on The Colbert Report.

To their credit, their scholarship helped to establish a framework for my college game design 101 class—e.g., games must have rules and win states, and there are clearly defined categorizations between genres and subgenres. This, however, proved to be a burden. Throughout the course, my teacher was constantly contradicting facets of the curriculum to make important points about how centralizing ideas like “win states” otherizes works by marginalized developers, among other ideas—even going so far as to incorporate games by Edmund McMillen as examples.

Stephen Beirne writes games criticism that considers a variety of fields. He works full-time and takes Patreon donations. Zolani is building bridges between alternative games and arts criticism practically from the ground up, but still lives at home and struggles to find work. Lana Polansky, who popularized the actual term “games criticism”, remains a champion of multi-discplinary and interdisciplinary games criticism, but is still pigeon-holed entirely as a social critic of games, and she’s been around nearly twice as long as Zolani or myself. There are countless other stories.

This isn’t to conflate Games Formalism with all of Games Academia. The “formalists” are a specific group of people, and most of them are far better off than their diverse group of peers in smaller or less established programs doing work in less systems-focused areas of game studies.

There is, in particular, a lot more to say about the history of the “formalists” and their relationship with academia and the privileges associated. Todd Harper wrote a post on his Tumblr explaining a lot of it much better than I can, but to pull a severely relevant quote:

Being in a tenured professorship — or even a non-tenured one — carries a degree of social capital simply by existing. If you’re at a big name university, it’s enhanced. Frank Lantz works at New York University, and just having its name on your business card opens doors for you. I know this to be true personally, as I was very fortunate to spend four years as an employee of MIT. That name opens doors for you because it’s got a history of respect behind it. There’s also the issue of academic pedigree. Who was your dissertation advisor, or who was on your committee. Who have you read? Who can you cite? Who’s on your speed dial if things get weird? Social capital.



Not Being Cited Or Otherwise Engaged With Does Not Make Me Feel “Smart.”

Formalists have done a pretty bad job engaging either with the work of my peers or my self, or respectfully engaging with us on a personal level. Debate, or healthy discussion, is not born of abortive dismissal of the approach of less recognized and poorer writers under the guise of calling us “smart” and “young,” and in no memorable instance have noted arguments between formalists and other groups served to increase the stature or recognition of either party involved. Given all this, these conversations have existed purely to punch down at these writers and their ideas, lest a significant challenge to the status quo be allowed to manifest. I again cite the previously quoted tweet.

When talking down is not happening to me or my peers directly, it is also happening without a chance to respond. Frank Lantz’ recent blog post, discussing his views on formalism and largely disparaging narratological studies, didn’t even come to my attention till at least a week after it was published because it was not directed our way (or at least my way) by Lantz himself. It argues against the views presented in a Storify that cites me along with tons of other writers discussing “ludocentrism” and “ludofundamentalism.” What it doesn’t take into account is that the views, critical approaches and games canons represented by the totality of the people in that storify, each of whom I still find personable and many of whom I am friendly with, are often in constructive conflict. If you’ll read those tweets, for example, you’ll notice the first tweet is me coining “ludocentrism,” and then Stephen Beirne suggesting his “ludofundamentalism,” because he prefers it semantically. Lantz rhetorically links these contrary views together as simply people opposed to games “formalism,” and even invents the term “ludo-essentialism” to make this discussion seem more conflicted than it actually is. He sloppily and carelessly reduces a diverse discussion into a polemic that only serves his narrow rhetoric. Lantz carries so little respect for my ideas and the ideas of my peers that he can’t bother to even speak to us about our ideas in our own contexts and terms. He didn’t even try.


Also:

I won’t personally claim to feel harassed or discomforted as the result of people I don’t follow or who don’t follow me popping into my mentions, but close personal friends have reported these feelings of discomfort to me. That said, if I don’t name tag you, I don’t want to talk to you, end of story. This is likely because I have good reason. To prevent this from happening, see below.


(dis)Engage.

“..[It] was so apparent, even back then, a couple years ago, that many of those people never took me or my peers very seriously, or our approaches, or the games we were interested in, but still took the authority to speak to us as if we weren't also critics/scholars. [...] Why do these folks continuously disrespect me and my peers yet expect me to care about what they think?”

Zolani Stewart, on Twitter

Engage honestly, or do not expect honest engagement. Here I have attempted to engage honestly, and that is something that has felt lacking not just in the most recent spats, but in more or less the entire short history of this time-sink of an ideological struggle. This is especially tragic as I feel I’ve made particular effort to know the value of the work these figures have produced, especially as, if nothing else, practical advice for developers looking to make particular kinds of games, especially with Raph Koster. These are probably people who young game designers could get good advice from, but the more time passes, the more toxic and hostile our engagements become, and it becomes impossible for me to seriously recommend their work.

I tire of finding myself constantly roped back into a frankly needless debate with people who are not actually interested in my body of critical writing or that of my similarly-minded peers.

Stephen Beirne, from the previously cited article.

Honestly, that being said, I don’t see that engagement happening any time soon, and I speak for many when I say I no longer have intention of continuing a “conversation” on terms decided by “formalists,” when the terms have always been decided by the “formalists.” This is establishing a boundary for conversation in a new context, an alternative context for games writing negotiated between myself and all of the other great critics who are alienated by this establishment.

Thank you for your time.

Austin C. Howe, Seattle, Washington, 2015


This article was co-edited by Zolani Stewart, Lana Polansky, Iris Bull, Claris Cyarron, and Solon Scott, sometimes with significant textual contributions. Please consider supporting Howe and Stewart on Patreon.

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Brief Notes on #Oldgames

This was originally intended for Critical Distance Blogs of the Roundtable series for December, but I didn’t put it together quickly enough to get it in. So: here are a few aphorisms on New Game +, Replaying a Game, Nostalgia and HD Remasters.

Does New Game + Affect the Narrative of a Game?
In indescribable ways. To pull the most famous example of recent memory: Dark Souls. Dark Souls achieves a certain tone to it’s early game especially by making the player feel utterly limited. This is decimated by New Game +. In short: any sense that the player character is supposed to be at any kind of disadvantage is absolutely gone, and thus, in many cases, even the basic premise of the game we’re playing is destroyed. Chrono Trigger isn’t the same game when Chrono is just as capable of beating Lavos within the first hour as he is within the fifteenth.


I can understand why people might want to burn through a game on easy mode, but I think it should be acknowledged that the version of the game being played is certainly not an accurate representation of the game’s systemic or narrative ideas as a result of this. More like a Greatest Hits tour of the game.


Does Replaying a Game Distort Our Original View of It?
First of all, replaying a game is almost entirely beneficial for critics. I’ve maintained that the games I’ve written about the most, particularly Final Fantasy VIII, which I wrote somewhere around 10,000 words about in 2014, I would not be nearly as well-equipped to write about if I had not played the game something like 5 times for a total of at least 105 hours. The first time I played the game I enjoyed the game, but it wasn’t until successive playthroughs when I truly understood it, and I find that my understanding only deepens with each successive playthrough. This is largely the case because FFVIII is a good videogame with a lot of good subtext to look at. Each new playthrough reveals ever more subtle details. As recently as this December, more then 7 years after having published the near-comprehensive “Driving off the Map” on Metal Gear Solid 2, James Howell still produced new and interesting insights on twitter about Rose’s relationship with Raiden and how it reflects Raiden’s relationship with the player.


I believe it was Film Crit HULK who once said that you haven’t really seen a movie until you’ve seen it twice, that the second time is the first time you’re really seeing how all of the pieces fit together. This is true for games, and I believe that the more you play a game, the better you are likely to be at writing noteworthy observations on it.


That said, I do think a key distortion takes place, namely, that the more you play a game and thus, likely, the better you get at it, the more likely you are to be way too forgiving of what I’ll casually call bad design. This is a particularly bad habit of Dark Souls players.


SOME DUDE WHO’S PLAYED LITERALLY HUNDREDS OF HOURS OF DARK SOULS
It’s actually pretty easy once you get used to it.


This is not helpful as a critic. What is useful as a critic:
  1. Using your knowledge of a game to help others play it.
  2. Recognizing when the game does a bad job of indicating important information.
  3. Recognizing when a game breaks it’s own “rules” to create new challenges.
  4. Recognizing that the problems people have engaging with a game’s systems is legitimate.
And most importantly:
    5. Recognizing that just because you like a game or find it interesting does not mean it is well-made, well-designed, or even just good.


Do Old, “Nostalgic” Games Fall Apart Under Close Scrutiny?
Obviously a case by case basis, but what I tend to see happening is almost the opposite. People don’t use their newfound scrutiny to recognize a game’s faults, they use nonsensical critical constructs to wreak havoc on an undeserving game, often for the sake of pure contrarianism.


SOMEONE WHO JUST PLAYED PORTAL FOR THE FIRST TIME
Ah dude, I used to really love Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver 2 but man, all those cutscenes. I mean like, shouldn’t games not even have cutscenes?


This is not criticism. This is checkbox review writing wearing a tuque and drinking better coffee, and it needs to stop. In short: we see a lot of game critics, especially those who influenced by the ancient perscriptivism, not use their abilities as critics to find out why a game works, but rather point out how a game doesn’t work under a set of false pretenses about what the game should be. It’s akin to grading a fish on how well they can run a race. There is a particular site that does this all the time and it drives me crazy. Hint: they’ve got about 7 million glowing reviews of God Hand and somewhere along the line the word “crunchy” got involved.


Rather then seeing critics point out how Japanese Role-Playing Games to do not adhere to the standards set by Western First-Person games, I’d rather see more writers set about decoding norms across genres and discussing their functionality. If a particular type of game uses a particular design trope incessantly, why is it there? Why did it exist? And if it has since been replaced, was that actually a good idea? Hint: the JRPG has been in a steady decline as turn-based battle systems have become less and less popular.


HD/Remastered Versions?
Look let’s be real here: console games are incredibly fragile. Pause for a moment and realize that no one actually makes the CRT displays that Final Fantasy VII was meant to be played on anymore, much less the original hardware on which it was meant to be played.


The process of making games compatible with current hardware is incredibly important for preserving videogames, and so far, the industry is doing an absolutely pathetic job of it. Case in point: I’ve been playing Breath of Fire IV recently. I’ve been playing it on a PS3, which is good enough, but that means I’ve been playing on an HDTV, which means that I’m getting a few frames of delay on my inputs and that my display isn’t entirely correct to how the game would look on a CRT display (even if I use the correct aspect ratio), but the game is still very enjoyable thus far. But what if I wanted to play Breath of Fire III on a similar setup? Can’t. Why? Because Capcom remade Breath of Fire III for the Playstation Portable! (Y’know, that handheld system everyone totally owns.) And they’re trying to sell that . . . in Japan and Europe where that was actually released. #GamesIndustry amirite?


Companies can’t be completely blamed for choosing their bottom line when it comes to these things, but problems happen when companies still see these games as viable tools for making money long after their initial marketing push when said games are not beloved classics of the sales tier or caliber of say, Super Mario Bros. 3 or Halo: Combat Evolved.


This becomes especially depressing when you realize money is most of the reason games of a certain obscurity will simply never see the light of day on a contemporary console. Can I even begin to explain how well a game like Terranigma would work on the 3DS even if they did literally nothing to support the dual screen? Or better yet, if they added a functional map system to that game? And yet Square, who owns the IP, will likely do nothing with it. Capcom knows that their #TrueFans hate Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter, so they’re leaving it completely untouched even for an emulated port on the PS3. Thankfully physical copies of the game are still relatively cheap right now, but that will change for the worse if the PS1 market of rare games is anything to go by. Protip: if you want a copy of NIER, go buy one now, while they’re still cheap.


That kinda went in a lot of different directions but here’s the short version: yes. Remake everything. Port everything. And if you don’t think you’re gonna make anything off of either of them, just dump the ROM for free on the internet.


And if your favorite old game isn’t available for legal purchase on a modern system, continue to emulate the shit out of it. Your moral responsibility to give companies money falls apart when buying the game would no longer mean actually paying the developer or the publisher for their work.


Thanks for listening.
Austin C. Howe, Maryland, 2014

Monday, January 5, 2015

Ludocentrism

LUDOCENTRISM (n.): A style of videogame criticism that attributes far more import to interactions, systems, mechanics, and metrics then to qualities such as narrative, aesthetics, or more abstract qualities, without necessarily ignoring that these latter elements exist.

Ex.: "Legacy of Kain games have really good cutscenes and dialogue, but I can't call them good games considering their combat is so shallow."

(n.): A game development philosophy which privileges the importance of the game's interactions, systems, mechanics, and metrics over their fictional context, aesthetics, or more abstract qualities, without necessarily ignoring that these latter elements exist.

Ex.: "We wanted the game to be pleasing to look at and for the story to be exciting, but we mainly focused on having good gameplay, since that's what we find most important, and what we think our audience finds most important.

Sunday, December 28, 2014

On 2014

Was It A Good Year?
NO.


Was It A Better Year For Me Professionally?
Absolutely.


Best Console Title
Drakengard 3


Best Mainstream Console Title
Alien: Isolation


Best Commercial Game Whose Strengths and Failures Reveals The Stagnation of Console Games
Alien: Isolation


Best Commercial Indie Title
Shovel Knight


Best Weird Indie Game
Idk but you could probably find out by reading The Arcade Review


Best PS4 Game
FFVII, as it turns out, is still not available for purchase.


Worst Game
Assassin’s Creed: Unity


Game I Liked The Least
DARK SOULS II


Favorite Movie
Captain America: The Winter Soldier

Best Movie This Year?
Fucked if I know, I think I saw maybe three in total?

Lowlight of The Year
Just as Gamergate was heating up, Robin Williams took his own life. A loss of one of the world’s great talents.


Best Metal Album
At War With Reality by At the Gates


Highest Concentration of Bangers on a Metal Album
Darkest Hour - Self-titled


Best Metal Album That Is Regularly Not Metal
Siren Charms - In Flames


Likelihood That An Album By A Band That Could Be Described As Melodic Death Metal At Some Point In Their History Will Be Next Year’s Album of The Year?

Continues to be extremely high.


Best Metal Lyrics
Who else? Anders Friden - Siren Charms


Best non-metal EP
Between Bodies - The World Is A Beautiful Place, and I Am No Longer Afraid To Die


Best Metal EP
Myrkur - Self-titled


Best Single
“From The Kettle Unto The Coil” - Deafheaven


Austin’s One New Rap Album Per Year
My Krazy Life - YG

Don’t Judge Me
My Krazy Life - YG


Likelihood You’re Gonna Hear About Big Projects Pretty Soon?
Extremely high.


Thanks for reading this year. Have a happy new year.

  • Austin C. Howe, Maryland (for the last time), 2014

Monday, November 24, 2014

Weird Sequels

I’d like to write about each of these games more individually someday, but until then, here’s a short list of one of my favorite genres:

“Weird
Sometimes Postmodern Sequels
Or Follow-Ups in Games Without Continuity
That Repurpose Their Series To Be Textually Interesting,
and Usually Receive Negative Critical/Fan Reception For Doing So.”

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
I probably won’t write much about MGS2 myself, considering that James Howell utterly demolished the topic in his classic “Driving off the Map”, but it had to make the list considering it’s easily one of the best videogames ever made.

Metal Gear Solid 4 Guns of the Patriots
Again, a topic totally destroyed by James Howell in “Monstrous Births,” but what makes MGS4 interesting in contrast to MGS2 is how it uses similar techniques to denounce repeating the cycle of MGS2 and MGS3, which built their meanings by reiterating tropes from the first two games. MGS4 intentionally reiterates these tropes in a meaningless way to point out how stale Kojima felt his series was getting, and that was matched with a script largely focused on stagnation, death, and disease. In all honesty, MGS4 is a tie for my favorite game and is absolutely one of the best I’ve ever played.

Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days
Commonly criticized for being a stopgap entry that does nothing to advance to overarching plot of the franchise, this handheld title also had tedious, grinding gameplay. But it was about something: this tedious gameplay was contextualized in the narrative as the actual jobs of the characters in the story, making for an interesting experiment in ludonarrative that attempts (and I think succeeds) in demonstrating how the tedium of everyday experiences causes lapses in the development of personal lives. The game even occasionally indicates huge time skips to keep up the pacing of the narrative, indicating, like real life, huge passages of time between genuinely significant events. And that this all effectively criticizes the core gameplay loop of the series is genuinely clever. The excellent cutscenes are available as part of Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD Remix which is overall a great package, but I’d still recommend laboring through the experience to get the full effect.

NIER
This one’s a bit of a cheat honestly, Drakengard and it’s sequels are already regarded as some of the strangest titles ever published on a console, but even in comparison to the game that brought us medieval characters traveling to contemporary Japan and then being killed by the military, NIER is still spectacularly strange. I wrote about it a bit here, and I think that piece still somewhat speaks for itself. The game is still cheap if you can find a used copy and that will change.

Final Fantasy VIII
I’m really cheating now aren’t I? FFVIII is infamous. Justly thanks to it’s absolutely bewildering mechanics that make the game impenetrable to many and joke easy to anyone who knows how to play it right, and unfairly thanks to a story that strongly de-emphasized the epic sci-fi/fantasy plot that had characterized the two genre-defining titles previous to and proceeding VIII. Instead, FFVIII was interested in . . . teen romance. Yeah, I know, it sounds bad, but this gives the game a fascinating way to explore and negotiate with masculinity, thus making an interesting semi-trilogy on the subject in the FF titles released for the PS1. Be not dissuaded by strange plot twists, this game has subtext for years. On top of that, it has an interesting aesthetic, some of Uematsu’s best music, and when you do get comfy with those systems, you will absolutely demolish the game’s balance in ways that only get more entertaining the more you learn. (And you don’t even have to master the card game to do it!)

Dark Souls II
Let’s be upfront here: Dark Souls II is a horrendous game, but in terms of it’s lore, DkSII seems to exist almost entirely to pick away at the tedious, thematically-empty pointlessness that is the lore of the original Dark Souls by pointing out the repeating cycles of tedium that define the impact of the player character’s actions. Also fuck the haters, Dark Souls II looks a lot better then the original game.

Soul Reaver 2 and Legacy of Kain: Defiance
In short: utter brilliance. The original Soul Reaver boils down to a fairly simplistic, unfinished revenge story whose main appeal is it’s aesthetic and it’s voice acting. It is, in retrospect, not very meaty. SR2 and Defiance essentially chucked the original idea for the plot out the window and made the series a brilliant existentialist commentary on fatalism, historical cycles, and power structures, and did it all in the context of brief, enjoyable games that were always top of the line graphically, and still look genuinely great today. They even managed to incorporate the fact that all of the games feature half-endings (largely due to bad budgeting) into the series thematic framework to make for a brilliantly ambiguous final cutscene in what is otherwise still an “incomplete” series. Some of my all time-favorites. I have an essay on Soul Reaver 2 coming out in the upcoming issue of Five Out of Ten magazine. Be sure to buy it, the money you spend supports myself and the other writers directly!

Chrono Cross
I’m replaying this one right now and taking notes. On top of having a great aesthetic, a great battle system, and easily one of the best soundtracks ever written for a videogame, Chrono Cross also makes itself interesting through it’s apparent disinterest in following any conventions of typical quality, even within it’s genre. For example, instead of featuring a relatively tight cast of highly backstoried and developed characters, it readily switches out people in a case of fourty-five playable characters. Seemingly each time the game builds narrative momentum, it sidetracks into something strange and disorienting. All of these make the experience of playing the game a sort of hazy trance that is at once incredibly difficult to describe and really, deeply satisfying, even if we end up finding the game ending as seemingly incoherently. I’m not sure I totally ascribe to that view yet, but what’s also worth noting is that Chrono Cross is notable for absolutely savaging the juvenile tropes and themes of Chrono Trigger, the beloved classic SNES game it is a predecessor to. Absolutely recommended even if the game only ends up being something akin to a megalong ambient music album, though I genuinely think the game has a lot more than that going on.

Monday, November 10, 2014

Some Notes on Detuning Electric Guitar

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F8S-F3DKA-8

So let's get a few things straight about this video because honestly, yes, I do want to spend time on this today.


  1. The guitar tone this guy is using is totally off for this sort of thing: it's farty as all hell, lots of midrange, not really much going on in the low end, and without enough high-end to make the notes really distinct either. I can only describe it like that and not specifically since Mr. Scallon didn't have any description of the gear he chose to use, not even just his amp settings!
  2. Now, it's not impossible to get good metal tone out of a Stratocaster like what the dude is using, but it's not exactly as easy as getting heavy tones out of any of the other guitars he had sitting around. For example, the EMG-loaded Schechter 8-string he has sitting there parallel to the strat he uses. (Note: not really a fan of EMGs or other actives, but it is gonna sound superficially "heavier" then whatever pickup is loaded in that stratocaster, in all likelihood.)
  3. The fact that he chose to use a six-string even after tuning well below B highlights another problem. Even with heavy strings, six-string guitars are not built to be played in, say, Drop A (AEADF#B), and guitars built for playing in those tunings tend to be, to put it simply, larger. The Statocaster he uses is built to 25+1/2 inch-scale, that is to say, the part of the string that is vibrating is vibrating over 25+1/2 inches. Even guitars that add extra strings for bass-register notes tend to add an extra inch and a half at least so that the string being tuned that low is still taut and has clarity of pitch.  Ibanez makes many of their 7 and 8 string models at 27 inches. Schecther's 8 strings are 28 inches. Ibanez's signature models they make for Meshuggah? 29 inches long. Without that extra space, the string isn't being pulled tight enough for those notes to be clear, or for the pitch of those notes to be compromised when fretted (because pressing the string with the same force as a tighter string will actually bend the string and increase the pitch of the note being played.) Again, using heavier strings, as Scallon does, counteracts this issue somewhat, but not as effectively as simply using guitars built for those extended scale lengths. Specific effects can be achieved by using six string, "average-scale" guitars for low tunings, such as the strange, sludgy-yet-buzzsaw-sharp tone that Thomas Fischer has been getting with an Ibanez Iceman since Celtic Frost's Monotheist, but to make a fair tone comparison between a riff being played in standard tuning and one being played in a lower register, that string tension must be accounted for.
All in all, while I get that this video is intended to be somewhat humorous, these factors combined make this experiment kind of a wash for me, as is the general question of whether down-tuning makes music "heavier."

Thanks for listening to me blab about guitar tone for a bit.


- Austin C. Howe, Maryland, 2014

Sunday, November 9, 2014

Press R1 To See Jack Cry

Let’s get it out of the way: “Press F” doesn’t work in Advanced Warfare and “Press R1” does work in Metal Gear Solid 3 primarily because AW is written by hacks and MGS3 is written by probably the most singularly talented game director working in the industry today.


That being said, the interactive mourning also works better in MGS3 for a specific design reason.


As highlighted in George Weidman’s video review of the game, “Press F” distinctly fails because it locks all actions to the same action button. The same button you use to vault yourself over cover is the same one you use to “Pay Respects.” This is recurring, as this great blog post about the failure of a similarly emotionally charged moment in Bioshock: Infinite points out. For whatever reason, there seems to be a strange disconnect between the universality of our own human limbs and the universality of an “action button.” Pressing the same button to open a door, punch a dude in the face, and place a hand on our friend’s coffin robs the latter of it’s emotional weight through some mysterious mathematics by which the repetitiveness of pressing the “action button” for each solitary action begins to rob those actions of their impact.


I’m uncertain as to why this is. That we use the same hands to scratch our butts as we do to cradle the lifeless husk of a dead pet doesn’t rob the latter of it’s impact in real life. But I do think that I largely agree with the criticism. For now I simply want to note that there does seem to be an emerging problem with the universal action button and move on, because other games, particularly, Metal Gear Solid 3, already seem to have figured this out for themselves.


In MGS3, R1 performs one function and one function only: first-person view. Mechanically this serves the practical function of allowing players to line-up anatomically sensitive precision shots to dispose of or tranquilize enemy guards or bosses. However, in a cutscene, MGS3 will sometimes prompt the player to Press R1 to see through Snake’s eyes, and this has a variety of effects from titillation to canon shoutouts to helpful tips. When the game came out, this was seen largely as a way to chip away at the perceived non-interactivity of the game’s cutscenes which, in true Kojima fashion, were even longer than the cutscenes in MGS2.


This, in contrast with the back-and-forth embodiment politics that defined MGS2, gave gamers a fuller sense of embodiment and control of the player character, Naked Snake, whose real name is Jack and would come to be known as Big Boss (I’ll refer to him as Jack.) Through this, the player builds something like empathy with Jack, by allowing us to look through his eyes and collect information or admire the craftsmanship of a well-constructed handgun . . . or ogling a woman’s body. (Hey, I didn’t say it was all good.)


Something interesting happens here, in that by encouraging the players to tap the R1 button, curious players find themselves occasionally pressing R1 when not prompted, and on occasion this is rewarded with unmarked first-person view opportunities. The marked ones, along with the regular use of first-person in regular gameplay, build an empathy with and an embodiment of Jack such that we become curious about him during the cutscenes where theoretically first-person view isn’t an option, and that empathy is curiosity is rewarded with yet more things that strengthen that empathy and that emobdiment.


We live through this character’s eyes for a significant portion of the game, and when Jack loses an eye, we notice this as well, our vision permanently dimmed by the loss.

This sense of embodiment becomes complete during the game’s final cutscene, wherein a defeated Jack goes to mourn at the grave of The Boss, who he had been forced to kill during his mission. As he stands and salutes, our empathy may lead us, yet again, to wonder what Jack is seeing, and if we press R1 here, we can see tears rolling down his eye and blurring his vision. We have taken part in many victories and many discoveries with Jack, but here, we take part in loss, and we do so because of an organic interest in the care, not because we are commanded to pay our respects.

- Austin C. Howe, Maryland, 2014